Main Newsletter
Mastery Series
Therapy Series
Bookmark and Share | Print Article | Items for the Week Previous | All Articles This Week | Next
This article originally posted and appeared in  Public HealthIssue 612

Joslin Replies to Dr. Richard Kahn’s Statement: "Diabetes Prevention is a Waste of Resources"

Physicians strongly disagree with statements made by former executive of the American Diabetes Association....


In a statement released today by Joslin Diabetes Center in Boston, physicians at the Harvard Medical School-affiliated research and clinical care center strongly disagreed with comments made recently by Richard Kahn, M.D., a former executive of the American Diabetes Association.

At a briefing held on Tuesday for public health advocates and diabetes researchers by the journal Health Affairs, entitled "Confronting the Growing Diabetes Crisis," Dr. Kahn stated that even though weight loss can prevent or delay the onset of diabetes, the failure of patients to maintain weight loss beyond an average of four years makes diabetes prevention programs a "waste of resources" and the health system should focus instead on reducing the likelihood of complications once patients have been diagnosed with diabetes.

In response, Osama Hamdy, M.D., Ph. D., Medical Director of the Obesity Clinical Program at Joslin Diabetes Center and Assistant Professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School stated, "Saying that physicians should stand by and allow patients to proceed to a diagnosis of diabetes is a disservice to patients and constitutes a surrender in the face of one of the greatest threats to public health the world faces today.

"Everyone who has ever struggled with reducing and controlling their weight knows how difficult that is. And they recognize that maintaining a healthy weight is not a one-time victory but rather a lifelong battle. That does not constitute failure but a recognition that they will have to make a continuing and often renewed commitment.

"Joslin's experience with innovative weight management programs at Joslin is showing that patients can maintain healthy weight levels well past four years. Our findings showed that people who initially lost weight, collectively maintained a weight loss of 7.6% of their initial body weight at three years in clinical practice.  At least 50% did not gain more than five lbs at four years. They reduced diabetes medication by around 50% at the end of the program and saved 44% on diabetes related cost and 27% on the total health care cost.  Eighty two percent achieved the target glucose control set by the ADA by the end of the weight loss program, and those who maintained the weight loss were able to maintain their excellent diabetes control for three years. The improved quality of life is worth every penny invested in weight loss."

"There is a legacy for the initial weight loss even if people cannot maintain it," added Edward S. Horton, M.D., Professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School, past President of the American Diabetes Association and one of the investigators in the Diabetes Prevention Program and Look AHEAD study. "The 10-year follow up of the patients who completed the diabetes prevention program showed that people who initially lost weight continued to develop diabetes at a lower rate over 10 years than those who did not lose weight, even if they gained part of that weight back." 

"Diabetes prevention through lifestyle intervention works among different cultures as shown in many big trials in the US, Europe and Asia,"  added Enrique Caballero, M.D., Assistant Professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School and one of the co-investigators of the Diabetes Prevention Program.  "Not having a full answer on what to do in the long term does not mean that efforts to identify these strategies and translate them to clinical practice model should be abandoned," he added.

Obesity and weight management are among Joslin's broad range of research and clinical care initiatives in basic research, clinical research and clinical care.  The work of Joslin researchers and clinicians has produced a number of significant discoveries and innovations that have been reported in peer-reviewed journals, including the discovery of brown fat in adults and the development of a series of clinically proven weight management programs.

Martin Abrahamson, M.D., Chief Medical Officer at Joslin Diabetes Center and an Associate Professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School, added "Since we know which weight management programs will work in the fight against obesity, the challenge is to find ways to implement them in communities, which we at Joslin are working hard to do."

Please email your comments to

Joslin Diabetes Center, news release 3-8-2012 Joslin Diabetes Center Champions Diabetes Prevention



Bookmark and Share | Print | Category | Home

This article originally posted 08 February, 2012 and appeared in  Public HealthIssue 612

Past five issues: Diabetes Clinical Mastery Series Issue 225 | Issue 765 | Diabetes Clinical Mastery Series Issue 224 | Issue 764 | Diabetes Clinical Mastery Series Issue 223 |

2014 Most Popular Articles:

Significant Weight Loss and Drop in A1c with New Combo of Lorcaserin and Phentermine
Posted January 16, 2015
ADA Issues New Standards of Medical Care for Diabetes
Posted January 02, 2015
New Guideline Released on Pharmacological Management of Obesity
Posted January 23, 2015
Handbook of Diabetes, 4th Ed., Excerpt #25: Specific Circumstances that Affect Diabetes Control
Posted January 04, 2015
Dr. Timothy Garvey on Qsymia and Other New Therapies for Weight Loss
Posted January 12, 2015
New Guidelines Recommend Off-Loading to Increase Likelihood of Diabetic Foot Ulcer Healing
Posted December 26, 2014
For Your Patients: Practical Advice to Rev Up Your Workouts and Lower Fatigue
Posted January 09, 2015
Phentermine and Topirimate ER (Qsymia) Studied for Type 2 Diabetes Patients
Posted January 15, 2015
FDA Approves Weight-management Drug Saxenda
Posted December 26, 2014
Advancement in the Artificial Pancreas
Posted December 26, 2014

Browse by Feature Writer & Article Category.
A. Lee Dellon, MD | Aaron I. Vinik, MD, PhD, FCP, MACP | Beverly Price | Charles W Martin, DD | Derek Lowe, PhD | Dr. Brian Jakes, Jr. | Dr. Fred Pescatore | Dr. Tom Burke, Ph.D | Eric S. Freedland | Evan D. Rosen | Ginger Kanzer-Lewis | Greg Milliger | Kristina Sandstedt | Laura Plunkett | Leonard Lipson, M.A. | Louis H. Philipson | Maria Emanuel Ryan, DDS, PhD | Marilyn Porter, RD, CDE | Melissa Diane Smith | Michael R. Cohen, RPh, MS, ScD, FASHP | Paul Chous, M.A., OD | Philip A. Wood PhD | R. Keith Campbell, Professor, B.Pharm, MBA, CDE | Richard K. Bernstein, MD | Sheri R. Colberg PhD | Sherri Shafer | Stanley Schwartz, MD, FACP, FACE | Steve Pohlit | Steven V. Edelman, M.D. | Timothy S. Hollingshead |

Cast Your Vote
Will you prescribe inhaled insulin (Afrezza) when it becomes available this year?
CME/CE of the Week
Presented by CardioCareLive
Category: Cardiology

Search Articles On Diabetes In Control